For months, attorneys whose corporations are concerned in litigation in opposition to Madison Sq. Backyard Leisure have discovered themselves banned from the corporate’s sporting occasions and leisure venues, equivalent to Knicks video games and Radio Metropolis Rockettes exhibits.
However now, New York legislators wish to get higher protections for ticketholders and shortly might take purpose on the firm’s use of facial recognition expertise in imposing their coverage — at the same time as the corporate refuses to again down.
Lawyer and longtime Knicks season ticket holder Larry Hutcher known as a proposed state invoice “a huge win,” as it will forestall MSG Leisure and its CEO James Dolan from denying entry to sports activities followers whose legislation corporations have ongoing lawsuits in opposition to the company big.
“We’re New Yorkers, we’re not gonna sit still, and see you act like the bully that you are,” Hutcher mentioned. “It’s clear that everyone recognizes that Dolan has acted in an arbitrary and capricious manner, it is based in a mean-spirited and vindictive way.”
Hutcher sued for the 60 attorneys in his agency, citing a 1941 New York State civil rights legislation in which a choose granted restricted reduction to particular attorneys for non-sporting occasions. However MSG Leisure nonetheless blocked different attorneys like Woman Scout mother Kelly Conlon, who was taking her daughter to the Christmas Spectacular at Radio Metropolis Music Corridor when facial recognition expertise recognized her.
“MSG instituted a straightforward policy that precludes attorneys pursuing active litigation against the company from attending events at our venues until that litigation is resolved,” the corporate beforehand instructed NBC New York.
A protracted-term season ticket holder has been banned from Madison Sq. Backyard for representing purchasers which can be suing the sector. Information 4’s Erica Byfield studies.
Whereas attorneys battle in court docket over whether or not MSG has violated the civil rights legislation, legislators are appearing on their very own to amend it, including a provision to guard ticket holders.
“Frankly, they owe it to New Yorkers to stop this type of bullying behavior, and allow every patron who wants to see a game or see a show at Radio City the opportunity to do so,” mentioned New York State Sen. Brad Hoylman.
MSG fired again on the proposed adjustments, saying “The fact that these politicians have so courageously taken on the ‘plight’ of attorneys representing ticket scalpers and other money grabbers speaks volumes about their priorities.”
A spokesperson for the corporate went on to say “We urge these elected officials to introduce legislation that addresses issues their constituents are actually concerned with rather than focus on amending a poorly worded and misinterpreted 80-year-old law.”
Courtroom and legislative battles apart, there’s nonetheless the continuing controversial problem of the corporate’s use of facial recognition expertise.
“Today it’s lawyers. Who is it tomorrow: Dentists, doctors, you as a journalist?” mentioned Hutcher. “Anybody who criticizes Madison Square Garden, they’re going to be on the list. So, there’s got to be controls. There has to be somebody who says, enough is enough.”
An legal professional whose agency is in litigation with MSG Leisure was barred from attending a Radio Metropolis Rockettes’ present along with her daughter and different Woman Scouts as a result of the corporate’s facial recognition expertise knew the place she labored. NBC New York’s Sarah Wallace studies.
Critics have claimed the tech is getting used to focus on perceived enemies of MSG, a declare the corporate rejects.
A spokesperson for the corporate instructed NBC New York that their facial recognition expertise doesn’t retain photographs of people, besides for these beforehand suggested they’re prohibited from getting into the corporate’s venues or whose earlier misconduct has recognized them as being a safety threat.
What began the controversy was a mom becoming a member of her daughter on a Woman Scot journey to Radio Metropolis. Conlon is an affiliate with the New Jersey primarily based legislation agency, Davis, Saperstein and Solomon, which for years has been concerned in private harm litigation in opposition to a restaurant venue now below the umbrella of MSG Leisure.
However Conlon mentioned she herself would not apply legislation in New York, and isn’t an legal professional engaged on any circumstances involving MSG.
That did not cease MSG Leisure from figuring out and zeroing in on her simply as she bought into the foyer earlier than the present the weekend after Thanksgiving. Safety guards stepped in, and whereas her daughter, different members of the Woman Scout troop and their moms bought to go benefit from the present, Conlon wasn’t allowed to take action.
“It was pretty simultaneous, I think, to me, going through the metal detector, that I heard over an intercom or loudspeaker,” she instructed NBC New York. “I heard them say woman with long dark hair and a grey scarf.”
She mentioned she was requested her identify and to supply identification.
“I believe they said that our recognition picked you up,” Conlon mentioned.
An indication at Radio Metropolis Music Corridor said that facial recognition is used as a safety measure to make sure security for company and workers. Conlon says she posed no risk, however the guards nonetheless kicked her out with the reason that they knew she was an legal professional.
“They knew my name before I told them. They knew the firm I was associated with before I told them. And they told me I was not allowed to be there,” mentioned Conlon.
MSG mentioned she was banned — together with fellow attorneys in that agency and others, as in response to their coverage.
“While we understand this policy is disappointing to some, we cannot ignore the fact that litigation creates an inherently adverse environment. All impacted attorneys were notified of the policy, including Davis, Saperstein and Salomon, which was notified twice,” a spokesperson for MSG Leisure mentioned in an announcement.
Critics of the NYPD’s use of facial recognition expertise to establish suspects say the instrument is inaccurate would not all the time work on individuals with darker pores and skin however the police division argue that the expertise is rarely the only real foundation for an arrest. I-Group’s Jonathan Dienst studies.
“This whole scheme is a pretext for doing collective punishment on adversaries who would dare sue MSG in their multi-billion dollar network,” mentioned Sam Davis, a associate on the agency the place Conlon works.
Different corporations have sued over being blacklisted. Conlon mentioned she thought a latest choose’s order in a type of circumstances made it clear that ticketholders like her “may not be denied entry to any shows.”
MSG said that “In this particular situation, only the one attorney who chose to attend was denied entry, and the rest of of her group — including the Girl Scouts — were all able to attend and enjoy the show.”
“I was just a mom taking my daughter to see a Christmas show,” Conlon instructed the I-Group. “I did wait outside…It was embarrassing, it was mortifying.”
Davis is now upping the authorized ante, difficult MSG’s license with the State Liquor Authority.
“The liquor license that MSG got requires them to admit members of the public, unless there are people who would be disruptive who constitute a security threat,” mentioned Davis. “Taking a mother, separating a mother from her daughter and Girl Scouts she was watching over — and to do it under the pretext of protecting any disclosure of litigation information — is absolutely absurd. The fact they’re using facial recognition to do this is frightening. It’s un-American to do this.”
A spokesperson for MSG reiterated in an announcement that security is their highest precedence and that facial recognition is simply one of many strategies they use. MSG Leisure additionally mentioned it’s assured their coverage is in compliance with all relevant legal guidelines, together with the New York State Liquor Authority.
Man Sues NJ Police After Wrongful Arrest With Facial Recognition